Quantcast
Channel: Opinion Articles
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15809

Letter: 'Lincoln' is not historical reality

$
0
0

Bill Howard's Jan. 6 article, "History lives, if we let it" is quite a good article. But I disagree with Mr. Howard when he appears to equate a Steven Spielberg movie with the enunciation of history.

I refer Mr. Howard to Spielberg's film "Amistad," wherein the movie depicts President Martin Van Buren as summarily replacing a federal judge. That is not history. Thankfully, our Constitution establishes a wall between the president and the judiciary.

I am not claiming to be an authority on Lincoln. But Mr. Spielberg severely discredited himself as a historian in my eyes with his depiction of the Amistad affair, and so I question the historical value of his movie about Lincoln.

And, yes, I view the Lincoln movie as some of his acquaintances do: as "pure entertainment," not to be taken seriously, as the depicted events may indeed not accord with the historical reality.

THOMAS A. WELSH

Delmar


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 15809

Trending Articles